I've seen a strong link between metabolism and chronic hyperventilation syndrome (CHS). I believe that I need to find out what that connection is in order to go forward in my healing. My CP is stuck and my metabolism is still low. I was hoping that one might solve the other, or at least improve the other.
1, First of all I am convinced there is a connection because I suffer from both, so at least within my personal organism there is clearly some connection.
2, Dr Buteyko (who discovered the connection between chronic disease and low oxygenation of the cells) himself writes this:
"Deficiency of CO2 caused by deep-type breathing[...]brings about alterations in metabolic processes."
http://members.westnet.com.au/pkolb/but_bov.htm3, Clearing reactions ("side effects" of practicing the Buteyko breathing exercises caused by reducing breathing, ie increases in CO2 and oxygen in the body) most often include, diarrhea, nausea, vomiting and food aversions. Ie, the digestive system seems particularly sensitive to CO2 changes, up or down.
4, Dr Buteyko noticed in his experiments that animal protein was very hard on the breathing, making the person more CO2 deficient. During intense training fasting is used because it helps improve breathing quickly. Interestingly ANY eating, of any food effects the CP negatively temporarily (kind of like how carbs temporarily increase insulin). This is fascinating for me since the primitive people clearly had phenomenal breathing and metabolism. For them, I'm sure the temporary drop in CP caused by eating a big meal, would have been insignificant (CP falling from like 60 to 55), whereas for modern people, it can be devastating (CP falling from 10 to 5 or so).
Although my morning CP seemed to go up during RRARF (likely because I only did 2 sittings per day instead of my usual 4 of Buteyko exercises during this time, allowing for the CP to normalize. When pushing the exercises, the CP often drops as a result of the intensity, but it's actually going up), my experienced breathing was incredibly labored during intense RRARF most likely because I was overfeeding so much, with a very low CP. Going to the grocery store, walking up stairs and lying in bed was all very difficult on the breath and I often had to do RB exersices just to get through the situation, not to mention sitting up several times during the night doing breath holds. During the bed rest period, I had to sit in bed instead of lie down. I can't seem to learn how to sleep while sitting, it's too uncomfortable.
5, Physical exercise increases CO2 in a healthy person, and is therefore good for the breath in a relatively healthy individual, however, if a person is unhealthy and has a low CP exercise should be avoided at all costs. Only after a CP of 20 seconds has been reached, exercise but only mild exercise, is helpful. Anything where CO2 levels risk getting lower would be counterproductive (like running while mouth breathing exhaling out huge amounts of CO2 and thus lowering cell oxygenation). As I understand it, it it is to be noted that even running with nose breathing on low CP might still deepen the breath enough to cause a significant CO2 loss. This goes along the lines of the 180 program: don't exercise until you are well enough to do so.
Dr Buteyko saw that his patients got more sick if they engaged in strenuous physical exercise, this led him to realize the importance of breathing, and in avoiding strenuous exercise in very sick patients. However, the Russian army noticed huge increases in CP among the healthy soldiers who ran long distances each day wearing gas masks, ie they didn't loose that much CO2 despite mouth breathing (or they might have been healthy nose breathers from the start).
6, According to Dr Buteyko relaxation is the best way to improve breathing. Any kind of stress causes both low metabolism and hyperventilation syndrome. Higher metabolism leads to less stress levels. It doesn't seem plausible to me that "a pinched nose" (that Weston A Price blamed for causing mouth breathing) would lead to hyperventilation, since a pinched nose would if anything reduce breathing rather than increased breathing, however, yes it is possible that a person with a pinched nose would get signals to the brain that too little air was coming in, although I doubt it.
7, I myself have a pinched nose, the reason I mouth breathe could be duet to this, but I would think the reason would rather be my allergies. The nasal allergies I had from early childhood, caused my nose to become blocked from over-breathing, (too low CO2 causes congestion). But this means that the over-breathing must have preceded the nose getting blocked in the first place.
I believe, since the muscles that are supposed to hold up my jaw is very weak and it's a constant deliberate struggle for me to keep my mouth shut. This would be due to the deformation of my upper maxillary bone. So, I think that's what causes the mouth breathing to start with.
Even if my mother had encouraged me to keep my mouth closed as an infant (like native mothers used to do according to George Catlin in his 1830s book "Shut Your Mouth and Save Your Life",
Free download available here), I believe that my poor nutrition had kept my jaw muscles weak and had continued to cause me to mouth breathe. It is with greatest difficulty and constant reminding myself that I nose breathe today, and when I sleep I MUST tape my mouth.
However, it is said that once CP is high enough you will nose breathe on your own no matter if your upper maxillary bone is deformed or not. Dr Buteyko never mentioned much anything - that I know about - on crooked teeth (although Christopher Drake who studied under Buteyko, said that "it's a known fact that mouth breathers have crooked teeth"). So, perhaps it's some kind of feedback loop here. High CP, high metabolism, nose breathing, normal upper palate. Low metabolism, low CP, mouth breathing, crooked teeth due to deformed upper palate. Possible?
The question is: what causes what and how best to go about healing it? I guess my best bet is to do both, increase my metabolism by overfeeding, ie nourishing myself while avoiding refined foods, and sugars, avoiding physical exercise and do sitting resting, and also increasing my CP by Buteyko work. Both RRARF and Buteyko say relaxation is key, and that exercising has to wait until health is stronger. So, resting seems to make sense.
I also believe that a low metabolism does give the brain signals to breathe more. Perhaps that is what causes "undernourished" people like myself to mouth breathe to increase the amount of air pulled into the system. Being in a state of starvation is in itself stressful.
Perhaps there is some kind of connection a la (I'm totally guessing here): low leptin levels (or anything else related to low basal body temperature) cause cells to not get oxygen, or the hypothalamus getting too little leptin or something, so the brain is given the signal that the body is getting too little oxygen. Perhaps some entirely other chemical in the body is reduced when nutrition is poor, this chemical perhaps signals the brain to breathe more, and this is why Weston A Price saw malnourished kids mouth breathing (note that all the children in the tuberculosis hospitals he visited mouth breathed, and therefore must have had very low CPs).
This is my problem, Buteyko showed in his many years of research that his patients -over 90% of them - did recover by doing his breathing exercises, however, none of them suffered from a lot of clearing symptoms. But today, many people (including myself) struggle with extremely severe clearing symptoms such as violent diarrhea and daily vomiting. This is especially true for people living in cities. On the countryside people's CPs apparently improve faster with less clearing symptoms, possibly because they eat better more nutritious foods, and may have higher basal body temperatures. With severe clearing symptoms people like myself are basically unable to get their control pause to go up, despite doing the exersices. But since my CP went up while I was doing RRARF, and only 2 sets of Buteyko exersices per day, I wonder if there isn't a connection between people's lower metabolism today. In the 80s when Buteyko was working, people must have had higher basal body temperatures, and could perhaps more effectively take care of the infections that got activated by the higher CP.
Perhaps it's as simple as a person with a low basal body temperature is less able to deal with the infections that occur once the CP rises, so the body has to resist upping it's oxygenation to protect itself from infections overtaking the organism due to a low body temperature. This potentially creates a situation where no matter how hard we try to up our CP, the body has to prevent this from happening to protect the organism.
8, Another aspect of the puzzle is that Buteyko knew that people would begin to hyperventilate if they got externally overheated. I find this link to be fascinating.
Generally, the higher the CP the lower the basal body temperature.....at the same time, clod hands and feet are typical signs of hyperventilation....it's all so confusing....
Also, in the night Buteyko recommends sleeping in a cold room with minimal blankets to ensure that overheating in the night does not occur. At the same time it is my goal to wake up with as high a basal body temperature as possible. That seems like a contradiction. However, the Peruvian Indians did sleep in freezing conditions but didn't seem to get cold, their inner thermometer was clearly high despite the outside cold climate.
We know that the overall population is getting lower basal body temperatures, and we also know that the general CP has sunk and is sinking. Is there a connection?
I believe the connections between body temperature and breathing are huge.
For me personally, my basal body temperature is low and I can't get my CP to increase no matter how hard I work, and my clearing symptoms are unacceptably dreadful to handle and seem to only weaken me more.
Complicating matters even more: it is also entirely possible that my breathing won't improve until I get a homeoblock to correct my upper jaw deformity since that might cause an overstimulation of my pituitary gland giving my brain the signal to breathe more.
I knew where to start? With the homeoblock, the basal body temperature, or the Buteyko exersices. Currently I do all at the same time, while waiting for the homoeblock. The risk is though, that I increase my Buteyko work, and impair my digestion so much I can't up my basal body temperature, while exhausting my faith in the method and my stamina in doing the intensely boring exercises for 2 full hours every day month after month. In that case I'd be not only wasting my time, but causing lots of damage to myself and eventually give up completely due to exhaustion. If I don't do the Buteyko work though, it seems that if I begin by upping my basal body temperature using RRARF, I'll have to suffer through a lot of difficult breathing episodes and in the end I may need to do the Buteyko work anyways. Not quite sure what to do. Wish I had more answers.
I've also noticed that the colder I am during the day, the better my daytime CP, but this means my body temperature is low all day with cold hands and feet and I'm not sure that's too good when trying to up my metabolism. I guess that the metabolism has to increase from the inside out though and come from an abundance of good nutrition, so I'll stick to freezing for now.